Like most people I was curious when the publication of “Go
Set a Watchman” by Harper Lee was announced. However, I wasn’t a huge fan of
the book or Atticus Finch. I saw the movie in Law, Justice and You class in 7th
grade (the same classroom where a certain classmate jumped out the window and
subsequently received detention). I read the book in college, and I never
really gave it a second thought until recently.
I put on my Kindle wish list and awaited the release date when
it would magically appear on my Kindle app.
But then the reviews started, and they weren’t good.
As the publication date approached I questioned whether or
not it was worth reading. In the end, I decided to form my own opinion and read
it. One of the good things about having a bout of insomnia and waking up at 3
AM consistently that week was it gave me time to read.
What did I think? It’s OK…not horrible but not great. If you’re
curious, I recommend giving it a try, strictly to form your own opinion, and not
base your opinions on what myself or others think. To elaborate:
1.
You can tell this is Harper Lee’s first attempt
at publication. The writing is rough in places, and I wonder what editorial
vigor was performed on the manuscript.
2.
The pacing was a little slow in places, at some
points I had to force myself to continue reading, as I sometimes got bogged
down in detail that really didn’t lend itself to the story.
3.
I got in confused in the lengthy dialogue at
times, I would have to go back and determine who said what, when, and who was
saying what now.
4.
The back stories of Scout, Atticus and Hank were
enjoyable to read and provide depth to the characters.
I would be remiss if I did not mention the controversy about
Atticus being depicted as a racist in this book. In my opinion, this was a
needed growth experience for Scout’s relationship with her father, and her
views of where she comes from, and what the current events are at the time the
book was written. I am being vague on purpose because I don’t want to give anything
away, but I feel the whole “Atticus is a racist” outcry is a visceral reaction
of some people who haven’t read between the lines and truly reflected on what is
being said. When I finished, I truly wondered what Scout was going to do based
on the conversation with Atticus, which is one of the things you do after
finishing a book.
Granted, those that love the character of Atticus would be
terribly disappointed in this revelation, but since I was not an Atticus lover
I didn’t have that same reaction.
When I decided to write about this, I originally was going
to base it off a story I read in Newsweek about how a bookstore
in Michigan is offering refunds for those that did not like the book. However,
I decided to focus on the context of the title, which is a verse from the Bible,
Isaiah 21:6.
The context of that Bible verse is a vision of the fall of
Babylon. The watchman is posted to look for and report “If he sees men coming
on horseback, two by two, and men riding on donkeys and camels, he is to
observe them carefully,” Isaiah 21:7.
The watchman (or sentry, as is written in my Good News Bible
from confirmation class) reports that he has been at his post, and confirms
that the men return, giving the news “Babylon
has fallen! All the idols thy
worshipped lie shattered on the ground.” Isaiah 21:9. (My emphasis added).
The chapter concludes with “My people Israel, you have been
threshed like wheat, but now I have
announced to you the good news that I have heard from the Lord Almighty, the
God of Israel.” Isaiah 21: 10. (Again, my emphasis added).
Even though it is weak, I end this post with some questions
for you:
Who is the Watchman?
Who is Babylon?
What are the idols?
What is the good news?
I encourage you to be your own watchman, and report what you see.